Journalist Accused of Libel Held in Court in Masbate; Cebu Journalists Face Libel Raps



CMFR/PHILIPPINES – A Masbate Regional Trial Court (RTC) judge held in court a journalist who came late for a court hearing on 28 April 2016. Masbate is 576 kilometers south of Manila.

RTC Judge Manuel L. Sese ordered the detention in court of correspondent Elmer Bandol for coming late for the hearing on a libel case against him. The case was filed by then Masbate Eectric Cooperative (MASELCO) General Manager Dr. Eduardo Margallo. This was after Bandol published in an online news website on 14 December 2011 that MASELCO has incurred financial losses of up to Php 314 million due to “mismanagement,” improper “procurement procedures” and several “illegal transactions.” (“314 million pesos losses of Masbate power coop traced to mismanagement-NEA”)

The report also tagged Margallo as the “Kissing GM” based on several sexual harassment complaints allegedly filed by MASELCO women employees against him.

Bandol was arrested on 15 April 2015 and was released the next day after posting bail.

Bandol told CMFR that the judge thought he was not in court. He was informed that the hearing would start 9:00 am,  but the judge decided to start at 8:00. Bandol’s case was the first to be called when he was still on his way to the court.

Charged with Libel

On April 17, suspended Cebu City Assistant Prosecutor Mary Ann Castro filed in Talisay City court a libel charge against the sister of her husband Provincial Board Member Grecilda Sanchez-Zaballero and editors and reporters of the Cebu Daily News (CDN). Cebu is 843 kilometers south of Manila.

Castro filed a libel complaint against CDN editor in chief Edralyn Benedicto, reporters Victor Anthony Silva, Ador Vincent Mayol, and journalism intern Margarette Managaytay after CDN published a news report based on a document from  Zaballero alleging that Castro’s marriage was “fake”. The report  “Mary Ann—Greco union nullified” was published in CDN last 12 April 2016.

According to an CDN report, Castro is seeking PHP 3 million in damages from each of the defendants.

Libel is still a criminal offense in the Philippines despite calls for its decriminalization. In October 2011, the United Nations Human Rights Committee urged the Philippine government to review its old libel law which it described as “excessive.” CMFR and journalists’ groups have been urging the decriminalization of libel for nearly two decades.